SEO Consultant vs SEO Agency: Which One is Better to Hire?

Reading time: 4 mins 21 sec

You’ve likely heard the magical word “SEO or Search Engine Optimization” talked all over the internet, offering to boost your website’s search engine ranking and attract millions of visitors. 

In brief,

FeatureSEO ConsultantSEO Agency
Ideal forSmaller websites, startups, or those with a clear budgetLarger websites, complex SEO needs, or those wanting a full-service approach
Team SizeSolo operatorTeam of SEO specialists (content writers, technical SEO experts, link builders, etc.)
CostTypically hourly or project-based fees ($50 – $200 per hour in 2024)Retainer packages ($1,000 – $10,000 per month in 2024)
ProsPersonalized attention, clear communication, potentially lower costWider range of expertise, ability to handle ongoing tasks, frees you up for other areas
ConsLimited skillset compared to an agency, might require more involvement from youA wider range of expertise, and ability to handle ongoing tasks, frees you up for other areas
CommunicationDirect with the consultantMight involve communication with different team members

The truth is that there are two basic ways to get this SEO success: hiring an SEO consultant or an SEO agency.

You may be asking, “SEO Consultant vs SEO Agency” or What’s the difference between the two?” and rubbing your head right now. 

We’re here to deal with exactly that, so don’t worry. 

Get ready as we take on the role of SEO superheroes for your website!

So let’s get started

Read This: 7 Reasons Why Your Business Should Invest In SEO

SEO Consultant vs SEO Agency

SEO ConsultantSEO Agency

1. An SEO consultant is a one-person army with an in-depth knowledge of SEO strategies, similar to a highly skilled martial artist. 

2. They can analyze your website, pinpoint its advantages and disadvantages, and then create a customized plan to help you rank up the search engine results page.

1. On the other hand, an SEO agency functions similarly to the superheroes – an outstanding team including numerous SEO experts. 

2. To optimize your website for maximum success, you have your link-building Black Widow, technical SEO Captain America, and content writer Iron Man working together.

Choosing Your Champion: What Suits You Best?

Now that the differences are obvious, which one is best for you? 

That depends on your comfort level as well as the requirements of your website.

Here’s a summary to help in your decision:

Hiring a Consultant:

  • Perfect for: New businesses with a defined budget or smaller websites.
  • Pros: Better personalized attention, direct communication with the expert, and maybe lower costs in comparison to agencies.
  • Cons: You might need to be more involved in putting the strategies into practice because of the limited skill set compared to an agency team.

Hiring an Agency:

  • Perfect for: Bigger websites need complete SEO services or those seeking a full-service strategy.
  • Pros: You may focus on different parts of your business and have use to a wider range of SEO skills. You can also manage ongoing tasks like content generation and link building.
  • Cons: May be more expensive than consulting, and there may be less direct interaction with specific experts.

Read This: 35 Best SEO Companies In Los Angeles – SWS

Let’s Talk Money, Money, Money

Of course, cost plays an important role. 

While agencies usually offer deposit packages, consultants usually charge hourly or project-based rates. 

For your information, here is a general range that may differ based on expertise and location:

Pricing ModelSEO ConsultantSEO Agency
Hourly Rate$50 – $200 per hourN/A (agencies typically don’t offer hourly rates)
Project-Based Fee$1,000 – $5,000 per project$3,000 – $20,000+ per project (depending on project scope)
Monthly RetainerN/A (consultants typically don’t offer retainers)$1,000 – $10,000+ per month (depending on agency size and services offered)

The Important Step of “Getting to Know You”

It’s important to do research before hiring the first SEO consultant you find.

For Consultants:

  • Request case studies: See their track record by looking at the previous projects they have worked on.
  • Schedule a consultation: Get a sense of their SEO strategy and communication style.
  • Ask about their experience: Verify if they have previous experience in your particular field.

For Agencies:

  • Look at their client portfolio: Check to see if they have experience working with companies like yours.
  • Read their testimonials: Find out how satisfied their clients are.
  • Ask about their reporting process: How will they keep you updated on progress?

Bonus Tip: Never be afraid to negotiate!

Read This: Search Engine Optimization For Orthodontists – SWS

The Most Useful Power Is Communication

No matter what path you take, your greatest strength is being able to communicate clearly. 

Be clear about the goals and budget you have for your website. 

Whether working as a consultant or an agency, the top SEO experts will be able to work together with you and clearly explain how they work.

Remember that you’re establishing a relationship when you work with an SEO expert!

The Final Showdown: It’s All About Your Website’s Needs

The discussion between consultants and agencies can’t be answered in a generalized way. 

Consider your comfort level, your budget, and the requirements of your website.

  • A consultant could be the perfect SEO partner for you if you’re a small business owner with a specific goal and not much money.
  • Using an agency can be the best option if your website becomes more technical or if you need a thorough SEO strategy.

The most important step is to get started! Your website might rise in the search engine ranks and get millions of new visitors if you have the right SEO expert on your side.

Are you ready to use every advantage of your website now? 

Now select your SEO champion! 

Whichever route you choose, keep in mind that SEO is a marathon, not a sprint. 

To see results, one must be patient and work consistently. 

But you can make your website a traffic magnet and watch your business go away if you have the right kind of data and a strong SEO partner on your side!

Regardless of consultant or agency, keep the following extra tools in your SEO toolbox:

  • Keep Up: The field of search engine optimization is always changing. To be updated on the latest trends and algorithm changes, follow experts on social media or subscribe to SEO blogs.
  • King (and queen!) content: Creating content that is both engaging and of high quality is important for attracting visitors and motivating them to come back. Focus on creating content that both speaks to and satisfies the search queries of your target audience.
  • Being patient is a discipline: Don’t expect SEO results right away. Search engines need some time to figure out how great your website is. But you’ll succeed if you put in regular work and have a good plan.
  • Track Your Progress: Data doesn’t lie! Track traffic to your website, search engine rankings, and other SEO metrics with website analytics tools. This will enable you to track your progress and change your plan of action as necessary.

Read This: 11 Best SEO Services In Pinellas Park FL In 2024


In this article, we will discuss SEO consultant vs SEO agency.

You will have no problem taking control of your online presence and the search engine results pages by combining the expertise of an experienced SEO expert with these additional tips. 

Remember that SEO is an exciting journey, and you can become a website superhero with the right tools and expertise!

Sunny Grewal

With more than five years of experience, Sunny Grewal is a genius at SEO. They have been helping businesses in managing the continually changing field of search engines since 2019. Sunny Grewal is serious about optimizing websites for search engines and likes to share their SEO knowledge through clear and useful articles.

Leave a Reply